Saturday, February 16, 2008

Madame de Stael: Not Your Momma's Moldy Bread

"In matters of the heart, nothing is true except the improbable."

Madame De Stael was born Anne Louise Germaine Necker on April 22, 1766, what is now known as Earth Day. Little Anne Louise was the daughter of Jacques Necker, the Director of Finance under Louis XVI of France and Suzanne Curchod. Curchod was the former lover of Edward Gibbon, no not the primate, the authority at the time on the Roman Empire, he wrote the book The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, that ID we did and never really discussed. Madame de Stael was lucky enough to be able to meet Gibbon, Diderot, and d'Alembert. Suzanne was highly involved in the salon culture of Paris. Madame de Stael and her mother were constantly vying for the attention of their father and husband, respectively.

Anne Louise studied compulsively and to the point where even her health was affected. She married baron Erik Magnus Stael von Holstein on January 14, 1786. She was very selective in choosing a husband, her parents did not want her to marry a Roman Catholic, so she had to search for a suitable husband. He was part of the Swedish ministry, and later became a Swedish Minister himself. Madame de Stael started publishing works under her own name in 1788.

She emphasized the importance of the individual in her works, a portion of which can be seen following this. Romantic writers often loved the rebel with a cause, but de Stael did not in fact love Napoleon. She believed he cared more about himself than he did about his people.

"There are only two distinct classes of men on earth: those who feel enthusiasm and those who scorn it; all other differences are the work of society."

—Mme. de Staël, Corinne


Madame de Stael expulsed her feelings about Napoleon in one of her letters:

"Far from recovering my confidence by seeing Bonaparte more frequently, he constantly intimidated me more and more. I had a confused feeling that no emotion of the heart could act upon him. He regards a human being as an action or a thing, not as a fellow creature. He does not hate more than he loves; for him nothing exists but himself; all other creatures are cyphers. The force of his will consists in the impossibility of disturbing the calculations of his egotism; he is an able chess-player, and the human race is the opponent to whom he proposes to give check mate. His successes depend as much on the qualities in which he is deficient as on the talents which he possesses. Neither pity, nor allurement, nor religion, nor attachment to any idea whatsoever, could turn him aside from his principal direction. He is for his self-interest what the just man should be for virtue; if the end were good, his perseverance would be noble."

De Stael has noted that Napoleon seems as though he is an inanimate object, that no emotion seems to affect him. She is disturbed by the fact that he treats his fellow people as though they are things rather than other living people. She points out that he was an avid chess player, which would make him geared more toward logic rather than feeling. He is not open to outside ideas and nature which is a romantic ideal, this is seen in the portion of the passage, "Neither pity, nor allurement, nor religion, nor attachment to any idea whatsoever, could turn him aside from his principal direction."

"The Abbé Sieyès conversed during dinner unaffectedly and fluently, as suited a mind of his degree of strength. He expressed himself concerning my father with a sincere esteem. “He is the only man,” said he, “who has ever united the most perfect precision in the calculations of a great financier to the imagination of a poet.” This eulogium pleased me, because it characterized him. Bonaparte, who heard it, also said some obliging things concerning my father and me, but like a man who takes no interest in individuals whom he cannot make use of in the accomplishment of his own ends."

She points out that Napoleon in his en devours only focuses on using those who can help him achieve his goals. Napoleon is extremely interested in one particular individual, himself. De Stael is interested in the affairs of the individual as expressed by this passage. We can infer that she is displeased with the fact that a ruler such as Napoleon should not only be concerned with himself, he should be concerned with the needs of his people as well.

Madame de Stael is similar in many ways to the Ivanka Trump. Trump like de Stael was born into a life of fortune, her father is a multi-billionaire and yet she has decided to excel. If she really wanted to she would not have to work another day in her life, instead she has decided to carry on the family business and work with her father. She, like de Stael, is very selective in choosing a husband. Trump could if she wanted decide to be a hedonist like Paris Hilton who was also born into wealth. Trump and de Stael are positive role models for young women, they were born into wealth and yet decided to work for what they want in life.

Sources:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_Louise_Germaine_de_Sta%C3%ABl
About.com
Excerpts of Madame de Stael's Letters about Napoleon

Sunday, February 10, 2008

How did growing anti-semitism during the late 19th Century foreshadow the Holocaust?

Events such as the Dreyfus Affair in France foreshadowed the persecution and autricism of Jews that was to follow during the 20th century. The Holocaust was a result of events over a period of time beginning in the 19th century.

Enlightenment thought influenced the direction France took during the 19th century. Enlightened philosophes were in favor of the toleration of Jews, but a few of them still criticized those of the Jewish faith. Voltaire, for instance, attacked the Jews claiming they are greedy and stubborn. Later his views were quoted by Anti-Semities as proof of Jewish inferiority.

Nationalism was growing in France in the 19th century, and along with it anti-Semitism. In Germany anti-Jewish sentiment grew as a direct result of Romantic nationalism. Far right French authorities during the 19th century were openly anti-Semetic. Catholocism had become the national religion of France, those who belonged to the Jewish faith were described as, "a nation within a nation," a phrase first used in 1793 by a German philosopher.

Disillusionment with the Jews was solidified by three factors during the 19th century:
  1. Those who opposed the progression of Jews in the economy blaimed Jews for their own misfourtune.
  2. Peasants blaimed Jews for the change within their spheres.
  3. Traditional Germans blaimed Jews for the changes in their everyday life.

Alfred Dreyfus was a promising young officer in the French army born to Jewish parents. He was accused of passing French military secrets to German officers at the German embassy in Paris. The evidence used to convict him was fabricated. He was convicted of treason in 1894, and sent to an isolated prison on an island off the coast of French Guiana. Evidence was eventually found that proved Dreyfus' innocence. His conviction was later overturned, but the damage was still done. Even though he was proved to be innocent anti-Jewish sentiment still grew within France. People still did not trust the Jews within France. The Dreyfus Affair set Europe up for the Holocaust because of its social implications.

Anti-Semitism can be seen as a result of misunderstanding and jealousy. Had those in France taken the time to understand those of something other than the national religion history might have been written differently.

Sources:

Monday, February 4, 2008

My DBQ: The Beginning

The rapid growth of Manchester England during the Industrial Revolution had repercussions that the people of the time period could not have possibly forseen. The social implications of industrialization caused a backlash which culminated with the deaths of thousands because of poor sanitation and living conditions. Pollution was also a major issue in industrialized cities, waste from mills caused the skies to be blackened with smoke, which was observed by the poet Robert Southey (Document 2). These things were to be expected, awesome growth often leads to social issues in the beginning of a period of change. England experienced a period of expeditive growth during the Industiral Revolution which raised issues such as sickness in the populace accompanied by a rise in the amount of pollution, critics of the time reacted adversely.

Inefficient sanitation and housing lead to complications that the government of England had a difficult time combatting. Edwin Chadwick thought that disease was a result of the diplorable conditions prevalent in the industrial cities, people were dying as a result of the lack of sanitation and cleanliness (Document 6). Chadwick's view may have been affected by the fact that he was a health inspector during this time, which would have caused him to be more critical of what he witnessed. What was beheld by outsiders was often just as critical, if not more than, those living in the cities themselves. Flora Tristan visited Manchester and found the conditions there to be miserable stating that (the workers were) "sickly and emaciated, their bodies thin and frail, their limbs feeble, their complexions pale, their eyes dead" (Document 7). The outside perspective is crucial because it illustrates how the conditions differ from those the person is used to back in their country. Ms. Tristian's view was probably affected by the fact that she was from another country with differing stadards of living. Primary sources from journals delineate facts that are unobstructed by the views of authors. The Lancet recorded the average ages of death in areas of industrialization versus rural areas, entertaining the notion that those who lived in industrial districts did not live as long as those who did not (Document 8).

Friday, February 1, 2008

How did British workers show their discontent with their working conditions (specifically uprisings)?



Conditions for workers during the Industrial Revolution caused people to live well below subsistance standards, to show their displeasure with their current state of affairs workers would militantly protest. We often take for granted our right to protest; protests during the Industrial Revolution often lead to charges of treason and death. During the Industrial Revolution British textile workers felt threatened by the influx of innovations. People did not want to have their jobs replaced by inventions such as the flying shuttle created by John Kay in 1733.


The movement was named for Ned Ludd, the supposed leader of the movement in its early stages. Historians are unsure if Ludd even existed. The character of "Captain Ludd" that has been instilled in British folklore, is based on the exploits of Ludd. The Luddite movement started in 1811 in Nottingham and quickly spread across the rest of England. The Luddites would move through towns destroying any mills they came across. The participants were numerous enough that the British Army was needed to help put down their uprisings. The British Army and the militants actually battled at two mills in Lancashire. After the beginning of the movement it was acutally made criminal to destroy machines.


Conditions were worsening as a result of depression and new matters by the English government. The Corn Laws caused the price of bread to rise higher than ever before in Britain. The Laws were tarrifs that were supposed to protect British corn interests. This along with the poor harvest of 1816 disillusioned the Britsh people even more.


Wokers began to create secret committes, those in Nottingham were held at the Pentrich textile facility. The protest was the brainchild of William Stevens and Thomas Bacon, who were a needle maker and a frame knitter respectively. Along with the help of Jeremiah Brandreth they planned on breaking into an iron works company and stealing the supplies they needed to proceed with their militant uprising. The workers joined in South Wingfield and began a march towards Butterley. They continued to march until they reached Giltbrook were they encourtered some soldiers, so their forces scattered.

Overall the British workers of the textile industry only did what they believed was right for their situation. This subject is of interest to me because the right to protest is something I hold near and dear to my heart. I can't imagine living at a time when I wouldn't have been able to express my mind. There are most likely lots of spelling errors in this post, I cannot get my spell check to work. Please forgive me :)

Sources: wikipedia.org