Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Our Amazing DBQ Documents
Source: Article on chinadaily.com.cn, a Chinese-based news portal concerned with connecting China with the rest of the world.
A recent survey reveals that male homosexuals in China have exceeded 5 million. It's the first official statistics in China concerning the gay population.
Experts say the release of the figures indicates that China is now developing a more objective and tolerant attitude towards homosexuality.
- - -
Source: FAQ entry on Democratic People's Republic of Korea's official government website.
Due to tradition in Korean culture, it is not customary for individuals of any sexual orientation to engage in public displays of affection. As a country that has embraced science and rationalism, the DPRK recognizes that many individuals are born with homosexuality as a genetic trait and treats them with due respect.
Homosexuals in the DPRK have never been subject to repression, as in many capitalist regimes around the world. However, North Koreans also place a lot of emphasis on social harmony and morals. Therefore, the DPRK rejects many characteristics of the popular gay culture in the West, which many perceive to embrace consumerism, classism and promiscuity.
- - -
Source: Entry on religionfacts.com, a website dedicated to objective information about world religions.
As Homosexuality is not explicitly mentioned in any of the Buddha's sayings recorded in the Pali Canon (Tripitaka), most interpreters have taken this to mean that homosexuality should be evaluated in the same way as heterosexuality, in accordance with the above principles.
- - -
Source: Monika Kochhar of India commenting on homosexual behavior and life in India, except from Fear and Loathing in Gay India in BBC World News, May 17, 2005.
Homosexuality has been richly portrayed in ancient Hindu texts and temple drawings, it is even visible in the Bhagavad Gita and the like. Successive colonisations led to the Victorian morality which gave way to the subject being taboo. Also, the comparison between England and India on this level of openness makes no sense because cultural paradigms are poles apart in the two countries. Yet, I think we are making great progress compared to other developing countries in tackling extremely sensitive issues. We are building a open and absolutely free democracy albeit slowly.
- - -
Source: Samee of Pakistan commenting on the spread of homosexuality in South Asia, excerpt from Gay Pakistan- “less inhibited than west” in BBC World News, 2 June 2005.
After spending a couple of years in the USA (an open society), I believe that homosexuality can never be defended. The Lord has made men for women and women for men.
- - -
Source: Excerpt from Article on Gays living in Secrecy by Han Yue (pen name), Chinese Cultural Studies Online, 20th Century.
BEIJING (UPI) -- ``I've lived with this deep fear of discovery for years, and it knocks all the self-confidence out of you,'' he says, looking much older than his 32 years. ``Now I just feel inferior.'' Han Yue, a pseudonym, has been arrested twice. Once the police beat him and then informed his boss, costing him a promising job as a clerk at the Ministry of Culture.
- - -
Source: Cheng Chung-cheng of the ministry of the Taiwanese Ministry of Education officially condemning gays, Chinese Cultural Studies Online, December 28th, 1995.
A Ministry of Education (MOE) official yesterday compared homosexuals to drug addicts and questioned whether they should be granted basic human rights. Speaking at a public hearing yesterday [Tuesday, December 28th, I think], Cheng Chung-cheng, a director of student affairs at the MOE, said: "Homosexuals should not pollute others with their relationships," adding that education authorities "do not know how to handle this problem." Cheng's statement immediately sparked heated protest from a number of people present at the hearing who said, "Homosexuality is not a disease, neither a crime nor a tumor."
- - -
Source: Interview with Abdul Kadir, head of education and research at Malaysia’s Islamic Affairs Department, Reported in Asia Times by Mageswary Ramakrishnan, September, 26, 2000.
TIME: How does Islam perceive homosexuality?
Abdul Kadir: Homosexuality is forbidden in Islam. It is a crime worse than murder.
TIME: What do you think of homosexuals?
Abdul Kadir: They are shameless people.
TIME: Can it be wrong for two people to be in love?
Abdul Kadir: Love? How can men have sex with men? God did not make them this way. This is all Western influence -- and the gay people expect us to be open- minded?
TIME: Malaysia has three major ethnic groups -- Malays, Chinese and Indians. Is homosexuality more prevalent in some groups than others?
Abdul Kadir: It is prevalent among the Malays, I have to admit.
TIME: If homosexuality is just a fashion, why do you think so many Malay men are willing to risk arrest by your department?
Abdul Kadir: Like I said, this is a Western influence. They also operate very smoothly. Even if we know they are gay, we cannot arrest them unless we receive information about them.
- - -
Source: Dalai Lama Commenting in OUT Magazine, Tibet, 1994.
In a 1994 interview with OUT Magazine, the Dalai Lama explained, "If someone comes to me and asks whether [homosexuality] is okay or not, I will ask...'What is your companion's opinion?' If you both agree, then I think I would say, if two males or two females voluntarily agree to have mutual satisfaction without further implication of harming others, then it is okay."
- - -
Source: Dalai Lama on Homosexuality, Beyond Dogma, 1996.
He explains in his book Beyond Dogma: "homosexuality, whether it is between men or between women, is not improper in itself. What is improper is the use of organs already defined as inappropriate for sexual contact." In 1997 he explained that the basis of that teaching was unknown to him and that he at least had some "willingness to consider the possibility that some of the teachings may be specific to a particular cultural and historic context."
- - -
Source: Homosexuality, portion of an article discussing homosexuality laws around the world, specifically in Asia, 2007
"In considering this information, it is important to keep in mind that the existence of harsh legal consequences for homosexuality does not necessarily result in people being prosecuted. In Afghanistan, for instance, there is a widespread tradition of male homosexuality. Estimates of the number of Afghan men who engage in sex with teenage boys or other men at some time in their lives range from 18-50%. This unusually high frequency is quite surprising since Islamic law in Afghanistan mandates that sodomy be punished by being burned at the stake, pushed off of a cliff, or crushed under a toppled wall. In 1998, three homosexual men were executed in the city of Kandahar by the then ruling ultraconservative Taliban by having a tank push a brick wall over on them.
There is a curious double standard in regards to anti-homosexual laws--they do not always apply to lesbians. This may be due to the fact that the existence of female homosexuality is less likely to be socially acknowledged or that it is considered acceptable behavior, at least in private. This double standard is most common in the South Pacific Islands, the non-Islamic nations of Africa, and some Caribbean Islands on which a high percentage of the population has Sub-Saharan African ancestral roots. Governments may even officially deny that any form of homosexuality occurs. This apparently has been the the case in Albania, Bangladesh, Congo, Lebanon, and Liberia."
- - -
Source: Comment from an American left on a BBC article entitled, Fear and Loathing in Gay India, published BBC May 17, 2005
"It is evident from the Kamasutra and the sculptures at Kajuraho that ancient Hindu India recognized and probably accepted homosexual practices. It was only the advent of the intolerant puritanical Islamic and Christian conquerors of India that has brought Indians to their present despicable state of intolerance of homosexuality and for that matter anything that is not orthodox. Hinduism is a tolerant religion but Indians are not a tolerant people. "
- - -
Source: Excerpt from an article entitled Homosexuality and Hinduism by Ruth Vanita, 2005
Hindu texts have discussed variations in gender and sexuality for over two millennia. Like the erotic sculptures on ancient Hindu temples at Khajuraho and Konarak, sacred texts in Sanskrit constitute irrefutable evidence that the whole range of sexual behavior was known to ancient Hindus. As Saleem Kidwai and Ruth Vanita demonstrated in Same-Sex Love in India: Readings from Literature and History, traditions of representing same-sex desire in literature and art continued in medieval Hinduism as well as Indian Islam. When Europeans arrived in India, they were shocked by Hinduism, which they termed idolatrous, and by the range of sexual practices, including same-sex relations, which they labeled licentious. British colonial rulers wrote modern homophobia into education, law and politics.A marginal homophobic trend in pre-colonial India thus became dominant in modern India. Indian nationalists, including Hindus, internalized Victorian ideals of heterosexual monogamy and disowned indigenous traditions that contravened those ideals. Nevertheless, those traditions persisted, for example, in the very visible communities of hijras, transgendered males who have a semi-sacred status and often engage in sexual relations with men.Hinduism sees all desire, including sexual desire, as problematic because it causes beings to be trapped in a cycle of death and rebirth. Procreative sex, circumscribed by many rules, is enjoined on householders, but non-procreative sex is disfavored. Most Hindu texts assume that everyone has a duty to marry and procreate.
However, Hindu devotional practice, philosophy and literature emphasize the eroticism of the Gods, and Kama (desire) as one of the four aims of life. In the earliest texts Kama is a universal principle of attraction. In the first millennium C.E., he becomes the God of love, a beautiful youth, who shoots irresistible arrows at people, uniting them with those they are destined to love, regardless of social inappropriateness.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
Notes
- http://anthro.palomar.edu/marriage/marriage_6.htm
- Shows African and Asian countries where penalties apply for being homosexual. Being a lesbian is not always criminalized.
"In considering this information, it is important to keep in mind that the existence of harsh legal consequences for homosexuality does not necessarily result in people being prosecuted. In Afghanistan, for instance, there is a widespread tradition of male homosexuality. Estimates of the number of Afghan men who engage in sex with teenage boys or other men at some time in their lives range from 18-50%. This unusually high frequency is quite surprising since Islamic law in Afghanistan mandates that sodomy be punished by being burned at the stake, pushed off of a cliff, or crushed under a toppled wall. In 1998, three homosexual men were executed in the city of Kandahar by the then ruling ultraconservative Taliban by having a tank push a brick wall over on them.
There is a curious double standard in regards to anti-homosexual laws--they do not always apply to lesbians. This may be due to the fact that the existence of female homosexuality is less likely to be socially acknowledged or that it is considered acceptable behavior, at least in private. This double standard is most common in the South Pacific Islands, the non-Islamic nations of Africa, and some Caribbean Islands on which a high percentage of the population has Sub-Saharan African ancestral roots. Governments may even officially deny that any form of homosexuality occurs. This apparently has been the the case in Albania, Bangladesh, Congo, Lebanon, and Liberia."
Homosexuality laws do not apply to lesbians more often than not.
- http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4304081.stm
- "It is evident from the Kamasutra and the sculptures at Kajuraho that ancient Hindu India recognized and probably accepted homosexual practices. It was only the advent of the intolerant puritanical Islamic and Christian conquerors of India that has brought Indians to their present despicable state of intolerance of homosexuality and for that matter anything that is not orthodox. Hinduism is a tolerant religion but Indians are not a tolerant people. "
Kishore, USA - This source asserts that ancient Hindus probably accepted homosexuality. This person claims that the only reason that practices were changed was from the influence of Islamic and Christian beliefs.
- As a gay boy myself in a Chinese university, I don't feel much social pressure imposed on me, because there are also some other guys who are homosexual on my campus. Some of us know each other well and develop some very normal friendships. We exchange views on life and help each other solve some of the psychological problems. We don't try to expect social acceptance for us, but try to establish a soothing environment among ourselves.
Danny, China - This boy from China accepts that he will not be socially accepted and tries to live his life to the best of his ability under his current situation.
- http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/3001126.stm
- "largely invisible gay community"
- A 141-year-old law prohibits "unnatural" sexual acts.
The book is being seen as a symbol of the growing confidence of Indian gay men, best exemplified by their public behaviour in the western Indian city of Bombay (Mumbai).
- Society is changing in India, more is becoming acceptable and giving hope to those who were not able to come out before.
- http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/3622418.stm
- The court ruled that the "validity of a law" cannot be challenged by anyone who is "not affected by it".
- Laws reguarding homosexuality cannot be challenged by those who are not directly affected by them.
- http://www.galva108.org/hinduism.html
Hinduism and sexuality. Hindu texts have discussed variations in gender and sexuality for over two millennia. Like the erotic sculptures on ancient Hindu temples at Khajuraho and Konarak, sacred texts in Sanskrit constitute irrefutable evidence that the whole range of sexual behavior was known to ancient Hindus. As Saleem Kidwai and Ruth Vanita demonstrated in Same-Sex Love in India: Readings from Literature and History, traditions of representing same-sex desire in literature and art continued in medieval Hinduism as well as Indian Islam. When Europeans arrived in India, they were shocked by Hinduism, which they termed idolatrous, and by the range of sexual practices, including same-sex relations, which they labeled licentious. British colonial rulers wrote modern homophobia into education, law and politics.
A marginal homophobic trend in pre-colonial India thus became dominant in modern India. Indian nationalists, including Hindus, internalized Victorian ideals of heterosexual monogamy and disowned indigenous traditions that contravened those ideals. Nevertheless, those traditions persisted, for example, in the very visible communities of hijras, transgendered males who have a semi-sacred status and often engage in sexual relations with men.
Hinduism sees all desire, including sexual desire, as problematic because it causes beings to be trapped in a cycle of death and rebirth. Procreative sex, circumscribed by many rules, is enjoined on householders, but non-procreative sex is disfavored. Most Hindu texts assume that everyone has a duty to marry and procreate.
However, Hindu devotional practice, philosophy and literature emphasize the eroticism of the Gods, and Kama (desire) as one of the four aims of life. In the earliest texts Kama is a universal principle of attraction. In the first millennium C.E., he becomes the God of love, a beautiful youth, who shoots irresistible arrows at people, uniting them with those they are destined to love, regardless of social inappropriateness.
- Addresses the idea that views of homosexuality were changed by Westerners and not by Hindus themselves. Desire itself was seen as the main problem.
- http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,474512,00.html
- It's In to Be Out
- When Goh proclaimed that "in time, the population will understand that some people are born that way � but they are like you and me," he seemed to these groups to be talking from some kind of social space capsule, viewing Earth at a fantastic distance�because Singapore has been changing quicker, in terms of social attitudes, than anyone presumed. Despite the laws or perceived familial disapproval, the republic's gay life is more open than that of most other cities in Asia, even Hong Kong.
On a walk down Tanjong Pagar in Chinatown on Friday or Saturday night, the gay (or straight) visitor will be impressed by the vivacity of the area: a clutch of discos, bars and restaurants, with guys and gals in their hundreds wandering from one rowdy place to another, often arm in arm (although kissing in public seems to still be taboo, even in gay venues). Gay life is not confined to a pink ghetto, though. There's a lively disco at Centro, opposite the venerable Fullerton hotel, that stages a gay event on Sunday nights just a short walk from the High Court. On the same night, the nearby Embassy Club, part of the new Esplanade concert hall complex, hosts another.
- Singapore is often viewed as one of he most harsh persecutors in terms of it's laws. Interestingly enough, it has one of the fastest changing social attitudes.
- http://www.utopia-asia.com/unews/article_2004_11_14_223637.htm
- Without realizing that the horse has already left the barn, Dr Sadasivan went on to say that the "CDC must ensure that saunas in Singapore do not become San Francisco style bath-houses."
- The government of Singapore is comparing their gay community to that of America's in a negative light.
Sunday, April 20, 2008
Marcel Proust: Possibly the Greatest Writer Since Shakespeare
In Search of Lost Time is Proust's most extensive work. It is composed of seven volumes which, in total, consist of more than 3,200 pages with over two THOUSAND characters. Proust died before he could edit the final three volumes, so they were edited by his brother. Within the novels homosexuality is a major theme; Proust was one of the first authors to openly discuss sexual orientation within his works. His main male characters are heterosexual but throughout the works they suspect their lovers of homosexual encounters with other women. Also within the novel characters are outed periodically. Other major themes of the novel are infirmity, which no doubt has roots in Proust's own life, and cruelty.
In 1903 Proust's father died, his mother in 1905. When she died his mother left his approximately six million dollars to be paid to him in monthly intervals of about $15,000. Proust spent the last three years of his life mostly in his bedroom, he died in 1922.
Sources:
Marcel Proust
In Search of Lost Time
Thursday, March 27, 2008
In the Beginning There Was Just An Intro and First Grouping
Sports were seen as an amusing enterprise that could also improve one's overall being. Sir Robert Baden-Powell saw sport as a way to turn young boys into men. He asserted that football, or soccer, could develop a robust young man as well as create their morality. [Document 3] Powell was the founder of the Boy Scouts; he of course was concerned with the well being of boys in general, observant of the moral and physical development of young men. Nikolai Semashko, a Soviet Health Minister, felt that people should focus more on their physical well being than doing well within their sport. [Document 8] Semashko, being a health minister, would of course be more focused on the medical aspects of physical activity rather than doing well at sport. Athletes of course saw that participation in sports would of course improve a person's muscular ability. Ingeborg Schröder was an accomplished Swedish gymnast who, in her autobiography, wrote about how wonderful it was to feel one's strength increasing as a result of exercises. [Document 12] As a result of having been involved in gymnastics, Schröder was able to appreciate the value of physical fitness and view its worth.
Sunday, March 9, 2008
Notes for Philosophy Presentation (full study guide)
European Philosophy and Literature (c. 1850-1914) | Julianne Tooher & Brian Ray
Philosophy
· Existentialism: In contemporary philosophy, Existentialism’s premise is that “existence precedes escence,” as Jean-Paul Sarte famously described it in the mid nineteenth-century. When exercised in this sense, this philosophy delineates a fine difference between existing, and being “of” something. For instance: one is born in
o Søren Kierkegaard and the Single Individual:
§ Kierkegaard believed in the idea of "the single individual."
§ Our belief in God is what makes our lives meaningful.
§ In Kierkegaard's reasoning we are able to obtain our highest state of being by bringing our desires out to be governed by moral ethics, this is what he referred to as a "telos" or what man should be. A person then loses their sense of individuality, but that is to be expected according to Kierkegaard, for once this is completed their life will be ruled by a norm. The individual will only know that they are living up to what is expected of them.
§ What if the desires we feel counter the ethics we demand? In order to fix this problem Kierkegaard asserted that within our own individuality itself there must be norms, "subjectivity is the truth."
§ Whatever is accepted by the majority of people is an "untruth."
§ Anyone that is living will constantly be faced with questions of meaning
o Friedrich Nietzsche and Nihilism:
§ Morality is not attached to the divine: morality arises subjectively, not through a priori (transcendent, pre-existing) universal morality. –Genealogy of Morals: A Polemic (1887).
§ “God is dead”: this phrase is first used in The Gay Science and also appears in Thus Spoke Zarathustra. Does not literally mean that God has died, but that, as a component of modernity, morality and a system of values cannot come from a divine universal orderliness. It must come from the individual. This lack of direction, because it is not easily recognized, causes angst and misery in most people—nihilism. The man/woman who can arise from this and form a new morality and a sense of purpose is the Übermensch. This archetype is portrayed most strongly in Thus Spoke Zarathustra, by the character Zarathustra, who functions as a Christ-like prophet that delivers a new message of morality fit for the times (epochal messenger).
o Later-to-come Existentialists: Albert Camus, Martin Buber, Simone de Beauvoir, and Jean-Paul Sartre.
· Psychology as Philosophy:
o Carl C. Jung:
§ A priori: His fundamental premise was that humans act in predictable patterns based on collective conscience.
§ The Collective Conscience: "a reservoir of the experiences of our species.” It is an objective and innate conscience that drives the individual toward mistakes through archetypes, intuition, dreams, etc., towards individuation and self-actualization. (We could not have a sense of self without an absolute to employ as scale).
§ Jungian Archetype: Unlike the Existentialist, he rejected tabula rasa, and contended that man was born into a set identity, and archetype. Lays his basis in mythology and dreams.
o Sigmund Freud: McMaken told us we are not allowed to discuss him, but this is where he belongs FYI.
Literature:
· Victorian Literature:
· Modernism: Began in latter nineteenth-century and was a move away from Romanticism, and Realist literature. The language was less transparent, and more nuanced, capable of portraying multiple meanings. Some common attributes of modernist literature:
o Incorporation of character perspective (text bears multiple subjective meanings).
o Rebellious in form (strays away from traditional literary structure).
o Importance of the aesthetic experience emphasized (through motif, juxtaposition, language, etc.)
o Psychology of characters a predominant theme, and important for flow and cohesion.
o Visitation of seemingly mundane topics (such as Woolf’s memoirs on motherhood).
· Modernist Wristers—active circa 1850-1914:
o Franz Kafka:
§ Kafka used extremely long sentences that could last up to an entire page, German language allowed this.
§ He also used ambiguous terms which made translation of his works difficult.
o Gertrude Stein:
§ Stein experimented with prose
§ Her novels were atypical narratives according to the standards of her time
· Within them she used fragmentation and simplification of their plot
§ Stein experimented with syntax and punctuation
§ She was also one of the first authors to use stream of conscious writing
o Virginia Woolf:
§ One of the initial stream-of-conscience writers.
§ Contemporarily studied as extremely feminist.
o Fyodor Dostoevsky:
§ Existential writer—wrote about characters finding individual meaning in their life.
§ The Brothers Karamazov: Nihilistic, hopeless mentality regarding purpose and morality devoid of God-like supervision.
o Joseph Conrad:
§ Exhibited Nihilistic viewpoint of morality.
§ Heart of Darkness a critique of the Übermensch.
o James Joyce:
§ Experimented in Syntax.
§ Although a critic of psychology, his literature reinforces the idea of archetypes.
§ Participated in the Irish Literary (Cultural) Revival.
o William
§ Yeats was a Symbolist poet for his use of symbolism and allusions in his works.
§ Used free and traditional verse.
§ Participated in the Irish Literary (Cultural) Revival.
o Leo Tolstoy:
§ Tolstoy believed that The Bible allows for nonviolence and nonresistance in the phrase, "turn the other cheek."
§ Tolstoy was referred to as a Christian Anarchist even thought he was against violence.
§ He ideas later influenced Mahatma Gandhi.
o Victorian Literature:
§ Occurred during the reign of Queen
§ The most popular form of literature during this period was the novel which was popularized by authors such as Charles Dickens and William Thackeray.
§ The Victorian novel often portrayed a theme of improving one's situation through perseverance and that love would prevail overall. Novels of the late Victorian period (1880s-1890s) were often more real than those of the beginning of the era. The idea of an "anti-hero" also was popularized at this time. The affinity for poetry during the romantic period did not translate to the Victorian era.
§ There was still poetry but it was not the main focus of writers. Elizabeth Barret Browning and her husband Robert Browning were prominent poets in this period.
§ Charles Dickens (1812-1870): Dickens' writing was satirical, he often made fun of British pretentiousness. Dickens wrote in episodes which made his writings cheaper and more accessible to the lower classes. His works often commented on problems he saw with society. Dickens' characters are often idealized to unbelievable extents. His works have be made into numerous film adaptations.
§ William Thackeray (1811-1863): Thackeray was also a satirical author whose most famous work was Vanity Fair. It was a ubiquitous belief during the Victorian Era that Thackeray's works were second only to that of Dickens. Thackeray thought of himself as a realist, he did not write sentimentally like Dickens.
o Oscar Wilde:
§ Wilde was known for his witty sayings.
§ Heavily associated with the Decadent Movement.
· Decadent Movement:
o Origins of the movement were seen in the eighteenth century, mostly from the work of Montesquieu
o The Decadent Movement was a name given to the collective works of writers who made use of Symbolism or were associated with the Aesthetic Movement.
o To be associated with the Decadent Movement was seen as a negative thing.
o Authors would use their works to protest the downfall of society and its lack of faith
o Experimentation in life and their work was a characteristic of these writers
§ Viewed by Victorian society as immoral.
§ Rebel against conservative Victorian society.
o Henrik Ibsen:
§ Norwegian dramatist—father of the modern drama.
§ Realist—exposed the façade of Victorian culture and the reality behind it.
Sunday, March 2, 2008
Is the US truly nationalistic?
I find our nation's sense of superiority to be a bit asinine at times. The fact that we constantly call ourselves the greatest nation on Earth seems foolhardy. In Melissa's comment I agree with the her assertion that since World War II we have been the world's police. This has given us the false notion that what we think as Americans is more important than the opinion of other nations. We need to stop telling everyone on the planet how great we are, frankly it must be a little annoying to them.
I find it interesting on every source that I have looked at (MSN Encarta and Dictionary.com), that nationalism is referred to as chauvinism when it becomes too excessive. So obviously chauvinists really love their country! Mr. Mcmaken really loves America.
Saturday, February 16, 2008
Madame de Stael: Not Your Momma's Moldy Bread
Madame De Stael was born Anne Louise Germaine Necker on April 22, 1766, what is now known as Earth Day. Little Anne Louise was the daughter of Jacques Necker, the Director of Finance under Louis XVI of France and Suzanne Curchod. Curchod was the former lover of Edward Gibbon, no not the primate, the authority at the time on the Roman Empire, he wrote the book The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, that ID we did and never really discussed. Madame de Stael was lucky enough to be able to meet Gibbon, Diderot, and d'Alembert. Suzanne was highly involved in the salon culture of Paris. Madame de Stael and her mother were constantly vying for the attention of their father and husband, respectively.
Anne Louise studied compulsively and to the point where even her health was affected. She married baron Erik Magnus Stael von Holstein on January 14, 1786. She was very selective in choosing a husband, her parents did not want her to marry a Roman Catholic, so she had to search for a suitable husband. He was part of the Swedish ministry, and later became a Swedish Minister himself. Madame de Stael started publishing works under her own name in 1788.
She emphasized the importance of the individual in her works, a portion of which can be seen following this. Romantic writers often loved the rebel with a cause, but de Stael did not in fact love Napoleon. She believed he cared more about himself than he did about his people.
"There are only two distinct classes of men on earth: those who feel enthusiasm and those who scorn it; all other differences are the work of society."
—Mme. de Staël, Corinne
Madame de Stael expulsed her feelings about Napoleon in one of her letters:
"Far from recovering my confidence by seeing Bonaparte more frequently, he constantly intimidated me more and more. I had a confused feeling that no emotion of the heart could act upon him. He regards a human being as an action or a thing, not as a fellow creature. He does not hate more than he loves; for him nothing exists but himself; all other creatures are cyphers. The force of his will consists in the impossibility of disturbing the calculations of his egotism; he is an able chess-player, and the human race is the opponent to whom he proposes to give check mate. His successes depend as much on the qualities in which he is deficient as on the talents which he possesses. Neither pity, nor allurement, nor religion, nor attachment to any idea whatsoever, could turn him aside from his principal direction. He is for his self-interest what the just man should be for virtue; if the end were good, his perseverance would be noble."
De Stael has noted that Napoleon seems as though he is an inanimate object, that no emotion seems to affect him. She is disturbed by the fact that he treats his fellow people as though they are things rather than other living people. She points out that he was an avid chess player, which would make him geared more toward logic rather than feeling. He is not open to outside ideas and nature which is a romantic ideal, this is seen in the portion of the passage, "Neither pity, nor allurement, nor religion, nor attachment to any idea whatsoever, could turn him aside from his principal direction."
"The Abbé Sieyès conversed during dinner unaffectedly and fluently, as suited a mind of his degree of strength. He expressed himself concerning my father with a sincere esteem. “He is the only man,” said he, “who has ever united the most perfect precision in the calculations of a great financier to the imagination of a poet.” This eulogium pleased me, because it characterized him. Bonaparte, who heard it, also said some obliging things concerning my father and me, but like a man who takes no interest in individuals whom he cannot make use of in the accomplishment of his own ends."
She points out that Napoleon in his en devours only focuses on using those who can help him achieve his goals. Napoleon is extremely interested in one particular individual, himself. De Stael is interested in the affairs of the individual as expressed by this passage. We can infer that she is displeased with the fact that a ruler such as Napoleon should not only be concerned with himself, he should be concerned with the needs of his people as well.
Madame de Stael is similar in many ways to the Ivanka Trump. Trump like de Stael was born into a life of fortune, her father is a multi-billionaire and yet she has decided to excel. If she really wanted to she would not have to work another day in her life, instead she has decided to carry on the family business and work with her father. She, like de Stael, is very selective in choosing a husband. Trump could if she wanted decide to be a hedonist like Paris Hilton who was also born into wealth. Trump and de Stael are positive role models for young women, they were born into wealth and yet decided to work for what they want in life.
Sources:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_Louise_Germaine_de_Sta%C3%ABl
About.com
Excerpts of Madame de Stael's Letters about Napoleon
Sunday, February 10, 2008
How did growing anti-semitism during the late 19th Century foreshadow the Holocaust?
Enlightenment thought influenced the direction France took during the 19th century. Enlightened philosophes were in favor of the toleration of Jews, but a few of them still criticized those of the Jewish faith. Voltaire, for instance, attacked the Jews claiming they are greedy and stubborn. Later his views were quoted by Anti-Semities as proof of Jewish inferiority.
Nationalism was growing in France in the 19th century, and along with it anti-Semitism. In Germany anti-Jewish sentiment grew as a direct result of Romantic nationalism. Far right French authorities during the 19th century were openly anti-Semetic. Catholocism had become the national religion of France, those who belonged to the Jewish faith were described as, "a nation within a nation," a phrase first used in 1793 by a German philosopher.
Disillusionment with the Jews was solidified by three factors during the 19th century:
- Those who opposed the progression of Jews in the economy blaimed Jews for their own misfourtune.
- Peasants blaimed Jews for the change within their spheres.
- Traditional Germans blaimed Jews for the changes in their everyday life.
Alfred Dreyfus was a promising young officer in the French army born to Jewish parents. He was accused of passing French military secrets to German officers at the German embassy in Paris. The evidence used to convict him was fabricated. He was convicted of treason in 1894, and sent to an isolated prison on an island off the coast of French Guiana. Evidence was eventually found that proved Dreyfus' innocence. His conviction was later overturned, but the damage was still done. Even though he was proved to be innocent anti-Jewish sentiment still grew within France. People still did not trust the Jews within France. The Dreyfus Affair set Europe up for the Holocaust because of its social implications.
Anti-Semitism can be seen as a result of misunderstanding and jealousy. Had those in France taken the time to understand those of something other than the national religion history might have been written differently.
Sources:
Monday, February 4, 2008
My DBQ: The Beginning
Inefficient sanitation and housing lead to complications that the government of England had a difficult time combatting. Edwin Chadwick thought that disease was a result of the diplorable conditions prevalent in the industrial cities, people were dying as a result of the lack of sanitation and cleanliness (Document 6). Chadwick's view may have been affected by the fact that he was a health inspector during this time, which would have caused him to be more critical of what he witnessed. What was beheld by outsiders was often just as critical, if not more than, those living in the cities themselves. Flora Tristan visited Manchester and found the conditions there to be miserable stating that (the workers were) "sickly and emaciated, their bodies thin and frail, their limbs feeble, their complexions pale, their eyes dead" (Document 7). The outside perspective is crucial because it illustrates how the conditions differ from those the person is used to back in their country. Ms. Tristian's view was probably affected by the fact that she was from another country with differing stadards of living. Primary sources from journals delineate facts that are unobstructed by the views of authors. The Lancet recorded the average ages of death in areas of industrialization versus rural areas, entertaining the notion that those who lived in industrial districts did not live as long as those who did not (Document 8).
Friday, February 1, 2008
How did British workers show their discontent with their working conditions (specifically uprisings)?

Conditions for workers during the Industrial Revolution caused people to live well below subsistance standards, to show their displeasure with their current state of affairs workers would militantly protest. We often take for granted our right to protest; protests during the Industrial Revolution often lead to charges of treason and death. During the Industrial Revolution British textile workers felt threatened by the influx of innovations. People did not want to have their jobs replaced by inventions such as the flying shuttle created by John Kay in 1733.
The movement was named for Ned Ludd, the supposed leader of the movement in its early stages. Historians are unsure if Ludd even existed. The character of "Captain Ludd" that has been instilled in British folklore, is based on the exploits of Ludd. The Luddite movement started in 1811 in Nottingham and quickly spread across the rest of England. The Luddites would move through towns destroying any mills they came across. The participants were numerous enough that the British Army was needed to help put down their uprisings. The British Army and the militants actually battled at two mills in Lancashire. After the beginning of the movement it was acutally made criminal to destroy machines.
Conditions were worsening as a result of depression and new matters by the English government. The Corn Laws caused the price of bread to rise higher than ever before in Britain. The Laws were tarrifs that were supposed to protect British corn interests. This along with the poor harvest of 1816 disillusioned the Britsh people even more.
Wokers began to create secret committes, those in Nottingham were held at the Pentrich textile facility. The protest was the brainchild of William Stevens and Thomas Bacon, who were a needle maker and a frame knitter respectively. Along with the help of Jeremiah Brandreth they planned on breaking into an iron works company and stealing the supplies they needed to proceed with their militant uprising. The workers joined in South Wingfield and began a march towards Butterley. They continued to march until they reached Giltbrook were they encourtered some soldiers, so their forces scattered.
Overall the British workers of the textile industry only did what they believed was right for their situation. This subject is of interest to me because the right to protest is something I hold near and dear to my heart. I can't imagine living at a time when I wouldn't have been able to express my mind. There are most likely lots of spelling errors in this post, I cannot get my spell check to work. Please forgive me :)Sources: wikipedia.org
Wednesday, January 30, 2008
ee cummings
Some may describe this as the car from hell, if you're ever unfourtunate enough to require a ride from me you will know why. When the car decides to move it is as if the heavens are smiling down upon you. Planets must align for the miracle that is the forward movement of ee cummings. I have the worst transmission on the planet, in laymans terms it's the thing that shifts. Mine is burning fluid at a ludicrous rate. In my mind I honestly believe that the people at Autozone refer to me as tranmission fluid girl behind my back. As Brian can attest when riding in it is an emotional roller coaster. Any victims the car may have that day are in a constant state of anticipation waiting for the next shift of the car.
The air in the SUV is thick with the apprehension of those within.
Will it shift?
Will it shift??
WILL IT SHIFT?!?
and....................................
IT SHIFTED!
and all is right in the world.
There are few things on the planet that make me happier than my SUV. I think myself a daredevil as I drive the car that may or may not decide to run on any given day. It drinks transmission fluid like Fitzgerald drank cocktails. How can one not love a car that would only drive in reverse for a week? I find myself relating to it all the time. It has issues like myself, but don't we all?